tjh at cryptsoft.com
Thu Jun 18 15:48:29 UTC 2020
We have a convention that we mostly follow. Adding new stuff with
variations in the convention offers no benefit without also adjusting the
rest of the API. Inconsistencies really do not assist any developer.
Where APIs have been added that don't follow the conventions they should be
It really is that simple - each developer may have a different set of
personal preferences and if we simply allow any two people to pick their
own API pattern effectively at whim we end up with a real mess over time.
This example is a clear cut case where we should fix the unnecessary
variation in the pattern. It serves no benefit whatsoever to have such a
mix of API patterns.
We do have some variations that we should adjust - and for APIs that have
been in official releases dropping in backwards compatibility macros is
The argument that we aren't completely consistent is specious - it is
saying because we have a few mistakes that have slipped through the cracks
we have open season on API patterns.
It also would not hurt to have an automated check of API deviations on
commits to catch such things in future.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the openssl-project