OTC VOTE: Fixing missing failure exit status is a bug fix

[Nicola Tuveri]

The vote is now closed, and accepted!



> topic: In the context of the OpenSSL apps, the OTC qualifies as bug
>        fixes the changes to return a failure exit status when a called
>        function fails with an unhandled return value.
>        Even when these bug fixes change the apps behavior triggering
>        early exits (compared to previous versions of the apps), as bug
>        fixes, they do not qualify as behavior changes that require an
>        explicit OMC approval.
> Proposed by Nicola Tuveri
> Public: yes
> opened: 2020-11-30
> closed: 2020-12-21
> accepted:  yes  (for: 9, against: 0, abstained: 0, not voted: 2)
>
>   Matt       [+1]
>   Mark       [  ]
>   Pauli      [+1]
>   Viktor     [  ]
>   Tim        [+1]
>   Richard    [+1]
>   Shane      [+1]
>   Tomas      [+1]
>   Kurt       [+1]
>   Matthias   [+1]
>   Nicola     [+1]

On Mon, Nov 30, 2020 at 2:03 PM Nicola Tuveri <nic.tuv at gmail.com> wrote:
>
> Vote background
> ---------------
>
> This follows up on a [previous proposal] that was abandoned in favor of
> an OMC vote on the behavior change introduced in [PR#13359].
> Within today's OTC meeting this was further discussed with the attending
> members that also sit in the OMC.
>
> The suggestion was to improve the separation of the OTC and OMC domains
> here, by having a more generic OTC vote to qualify as bug fixes the
> changes to let any OpenSSL app return an (early) failure exit status
> when a called function fails.
>
> The idea is that, if we agree on this technical definition, then no OMC
> vote to allow a behavior change in the apps would be required in
> general, unless, on a case-by-case basis, the "OMC hold" process is
> invoked for whatever reason on the specific bug fix, triggering the
> usual OMC decision process.
>
> [previous proposal]:
> <https://www.mail-archive.com/openssl-project@openssl.org/msg02241.html>
> [PR#13359]: <https://github.com/openssl/openssl/pull/13359>
>
>
>
> Vote text
> ---------
>
> topic: In the context of the OpenSSL apps, the OTC qualifies as bug
>        fixes the changes to return a failure exit status when a called
>        function fails with an unhandled return value.
>        Even when these bug fixes change the apps behavior triggering
>        early exits (compared to previous versions of the apps), as bug
>        fixes, they do not qualify as behavior changes that require an
>        explicit OMC approval.
> Proposed by Nicola Tuveri
> Public: yes
> opened: 2020-11-30